Taking It to the Next Level
Before I put my name in, it seemed so unlikely that I’d ever be called up. Which is half the reason I went ahead with it when my friend V punked out on me.
“Uh, yeah, sorry. I didn’t prepare a story. I’m just here to support you.”
Asshole.
I’m just kidding. It was fine, but only because I figured that if she punked out, I could too and we’d still have a good time at the show. But then I said something about not putting my name in to Erica and she wouldn’t have it. She had left work early to meet me and our other friend C came in from Brooklyn to watch, so I had to at least give it a shot. As usual, she was right and once we got inside I headed towards the front of the room to sign up. I grabbed the contract off the stage and took it back to the bar to fill it out.
“Oh my god, you guys. I can’t believe I’m actually doing this.”
When I finished writing out all my information and agreeing to be taped, filmed and potentially broadcast, I went back to the stage, folded my sheet of paper twice and dropped it in a tote bag that contained what looked like at least 30 others.
I returned to my peeps and my beer feeling pretty good because I was sure my chances of being called were pretty slim. By the time they got to the fourth storyteller, I had stopped even listening for my name. Which is why I didn’t realize the host had called it until V pointed it out to me.
“Susan. That’s you.”
I put down my beer, kissed Erica and made my way through the crowd to the stage. The host was hamming it up for the audience while the last person’s scores were being tallied, so I sat in her seat and tried to decide the best way to start my story.

Oh yeah, did I mention? I told a story at The Moth.
Ohmygodholyshit, right?
Now, if you don’t know what The Moth is, you probably didn’t have that reaction, but trust me, that’s the one you should have. And for the sake of understanding the rest of the story, I suggest you check it out really quick at http://themoth.org/about then meet the rest of us back in the next paragraph. Okay?
Welcome back! Pretty cool stuff, right? So, as I was saying, I went to The Moth, put my name in and actually got called to the stage. It was unbelievable. I went up, I told a story, I got a lot of laughs, I got a lot of “that’s so moving” looks from the audience, and I got a lot of applause. I also got some pretty good scores.

If you do the math, I came in fourth. But let me tell you something. Those judges were drunk after half-time and once they gave that adorable little lesbian (well-rehearsed, practically professional comic) storyteller those two 10’s, they were totally inflating their scores because they already had a clear winner. I am just saying.
Still, I was super proud of myself and once the show was finished, I went up to the stage to take that picture of the scoreboard. As I was moving the mic out of the way so I could get a clear shot, one of the girls running the show stopped me. “Hey, you did a great job. Seriously, any other night you would have won. That other girl was just crazy good.”
My brain exploded all over the stage as I said, “Thanks a lot, I really enjoyed doing it,” as if I was cool and did shit like that all the time. I turned around before I vomited or something, and headed for the merch table.
“Can I get a t-shirt and a tote bag, please?”
“Oh, the tote bag only comes with a $125 membership.”

Worth it.
Later Erica who watched the interaction from the front of the bar said, “I knew you were getting the membership as soon as I saw you say, ‘Fuck it,’ and hand over your credit card.”
Whatever, I would have paid more if I had to. Because, seriously, it was one of the best nights of my life.

















